Article

How can we measure and manage healthcare balance sheet performance?

VizientKauffmanArticle
By Robert Turner and Lisa Goldstein
6 min readNov 19, 2026
Financial sustainability
Key points
  •  

A novel view of not-for-profit healthcare balance sheet performance helps healthcare leaders connect financial return, operating productivity, resilience, and strategic flexibility.

Healthcare is a difficult business. Margins are thin, fixed costs are high, medical inflation is persistent, and leaders have fewer controllable levers than they would like. The industry’s response is to focus improvement efforts on the income statement: grow revenue and reduce expenses. While those efforts are necessary, they do not exhaust the ways an organization can improve its economic performance.

Healthcare organizations also steward substantial financial and physical resources, including investments, facilities, equipment, and liquidity. A balance sheet perspective asks a different set of questions: What are these resources producing? What risks are they carrying? What flexibility and resilience are they providing? Looking across operating income, investment income, capital productivity, financing, and liquidity can reveal opportunities that an income statement lens alone may miss.

Healthcare organizations have generally lacked an integrated framework for assessing the balance sheet as a whole and understanding how its component parts contribute to performance. To address that gap, Kaufman Hall has developed a framework that enables CFOs and treasurers to measure and manage balance sheet performance.

A balance sheet performance framework

Balance Sheet Yield (BSY) provides a way to evaluate the balance sheet as a whole and the contributions of its major capital pools. Unlike standard investment-return analysis or return on invested capital, BSY brings the full balance sheet into view. We use artificial intelligence to accelerate data extraction, normalization, calculation, and pattern recognition. Our team applies judgment about healthcare finance, treasury, accounting, credit, investments, and capital allocation to determine which observations are meaningful.

The framework focuses on three principal capital pools: long-term investments (financial capital); net property, plant, and equipment (operating capital); and cash and short-term investments (liquidity capital). Yield for each capital pool is determined by the economic return associated with each: investment income less interest expense, cash flow from operations, and earnings on short-term liquidity for each of the pools, respectively. As a simplifying assumption, short-term liquidity yield is assumed to earn 3%. The weighted average of the three component yields produces an overall balance sheet yield that provides insights both in terms of returns and composition.

The table below summarizes the measures.

Figure 1. The Balance Sheet Yield Framework
Figure 1. The Balance Sheet Yield Framework

Audited financial statements cannot establish causation or explain the strategic context behind a result, nor can a single audited year reveal a trend. The purpose of this exploratory balance sheet analysis was more practical: to create visibility, identify patterns among the sample, and generate better management questions.

Practical application generates insights

We recently employed this framework at an industry event using FY2025 audited financial statements from 44 healthcare organizations with median total assets of $7.7 billion and representation across the credit rating spectrum. On average, these three pools represented 75% of total assets (with the remainder being items such as goodwill and receivables).

We calculated the yield of each pool and combined these results to compute an overall BSY for each participant and for the sample. Median BSY was 9.1%, with individual results ranging from approximately 1.3% to 15.7%. The analysis showed that the pools do not contribute equally or in the same way; their relative weights shape the overall result.

Key observations:
  1. Balance sheet performance is a portfolio of outcomes. Financial, operating, and liquidity capital produce different forms of value; overall performance depends on both the yield of each pool and its relative weight in the capital base.
  2. Financial capital: scale and credit quality are associated with stronger net financial yield. For systems operating with less favorable scale or leverage, the findings point to financing burden and investment structure as areas for closer examination.
  3. Operating capital: larger property, plant, and equipment (PP&E) bases produced more operating cash flow in absolute terms, but less cash flow per dollar of PP&E. This raises questions about capital productivity for larger providers but does not by itself establish excess capacity.
  4. Liquidity capital: liquidity provides protection and preserves flexibility, but it carries an opportunity cost. The observed tradeoff warrants further investigation; the appropriate balance depends on risk, liquidity requirements, cash flow forecasting confidence, project timing, and tolerance for volatility.
 

What the analysis shows

Financial capital. When sorted by absolute size of total investable assets, net financial yield increased from 4.8% in the smallest investable asset quartile to 9.5% in the largest. Gross investment yield increased initially, while financing drag related to interest expense declined when comparing the smallest quartile with the larger three. Among the three larger quartiles, the largest pools produced the most consistent net results. Credit quality showed a similar pattern. AA-rated systems had a mean net financial yield of 10.2%, compared with 6.5% for A-rated systems. The difference was roughly divided between higher gross investment yield and lower interest burden.

Operating capital. Operating cash flow per dollar of PP&E did not improve with the amount of capital deployed; in fact, we observed the opposite. Across the first three quartiles ranked by size, median PP&E increased from approximately $0.8 billion to $2.8 billion while the operating capital yield remained between 13.1% and 15.9%. In the largest quartile, median PP&E reached $7.5 billion while median operating capital yield fell to 8.9%. In a separate comparison of high-PP&E systems, the weaker-conversion cohort required approximately $1.65 billion of PP&E per $100 million of operating cash flow, compared with $584 million for the stronger-conversion cohort.

Net Financial Yield
10.2%
AA systems
6.5%
A systems

Liquidity capital. Liquidity protects the organization against volatility, supports future investment, preserves strategic flexibility, and may reflect deliberate caution. It also carries an opportunity cost: capital held for liquidity is not available for longer-term investment or other uses. Audited financial statements cannot distinguish among these explanations, so we focus our interpretation on allocation rather than observed yield. Across the cohort, the share of total capital allocated to cash and short-term investments increased from 3.9% in the lowest quartile to 20.8% in the highest. Most of the tradeoff was with financial assets: allocation to financial capital declined from 58.3% to 35.2% while operating capital allocation remained relatively stable, ranging from 37.8% to 44.0%.

From measurement to management action

Measurement is useful only if it changes a decision. Low net financial yield may prompt review of financing burden, investment structure, and/or risk appetite; low operating capital yield may prompt examination of capital planning and asset utilization; and high liquidity allocation may prompt review of forecast confidence, project timing, and risk tolerance.

The framework elevates the importance of Treasury’s contribution to performance. Treasury does not own every decision involving operations, investments, facilities, equipment, or strategy. But it is often positioned to connect information across those decisions and help the organization understand their financial and strategic consequences.

The next step is to apply the framework over various timeframes, within refined peer groups, and against specific management choices. Its value is not a single score; it is a clearer view of what each capital pool is producing, what it is protecting, and which future choices it preserves.

Liquidity Allocation
3.9%
Lowest quartile
20.8%
Highest quartile

Authors

Smiling businessman in suit and red tie

Robert Turner

Managing Director, Practice Leader, Treasury & Capital Markets

Robert Turner leads Kaufman Hall’s Treasury & Capital Markets practice, with over 20 years of experience in healthcare and finance. He advises healthcare leaders nationwide on Treasury and Capital Markets topics, including credit and capital management, external financing, treasury operations, treasury platform merger integration and investment strategy. Mr. Turner’s capital markets expertise includes plan of finance development for public and...

Professional woman in modern office environment

Lisa Goldstein

Managing Director

Lisa is a Managing Director in Kaufman Hall’s Treasury & Capital Markets practice and a member of the Thought Leadership team. She is a nationally recognized analyst, advisor, speaker, writer and expert on not-for-profit healthcare. Prior to joining Kaufman Hall, Lisa spent 30 years at Moody’s Investors Service, including 15 years serving as Sector Lead as Associate Managing Director for...